Property Trust Guide

Disadvantages of Putting Your House in Trust

Understanding the downsides before you decide — risks, pitfalls, and what to consider instead.

Placing your home in a trust is often promoted as a way to protect assets, reduce inheritance tax, or pass property to children. But the reality is more complicated. This guide explains the key disadvantages — so you can make an informed decision with the help of a specialist solicitor.

Speak to a Trusts Solicitor Read the Guide

Trusts are not a universal solution — and can backfire

Many homeowners are approached with trust schemes that promise to protect their home from care fees, reduce inheritance tax, or pass property to children tax-free. In practice, these arrangements often fail to deliver — and can create significant legal, tax, and family problems. Always take independent specialist advice before proceeding.

The Key Disadvantages of Putting Your House in Trust

These are the most significant risks and pitfalls you should understand before placing your property in a trust.

Loss of Control Over Your Property

High Risk

Once placed in an irrevocable trust, you no longer own the property outright.

With an irrevocable trust, the trustees — not you — manage the asset. You cannot sell, remortgage, or make decisions about the property without trustee consent. Even with a revocable trust, your control is limited by the trust deed. Many homeowners are surprised to discover how much autonomy they give up the moment the transfer is made.

Difficulty Changing the Trust Terms

High Risk

Irrevocable trusts are extremely difficult — and sometimes impossible — to alter.

Once an irrevocable trust is established, changing its terms typically requires the consent of all beneficiaries and, in some cases, a court order. If your circumstances change — a divorce, a falling-out with a beneficiary, a change in your financial needs — you may find yourself locked into arrangements that no longer serve your interests.

High Setup and Ongoing Costs

High Risk

Trusts are expensive to create and maintain compared to a straightforward will.

Setting up a property trust requires specialist solicitor fees, which are typically higher than the cost of a standard will. If you appoint a professional trustee, you will also pay ongoing management fees. There are costs associated with registering the trust with HMRC's Trust Registration Service, preparing annual accounts, and filing trust tax returns. These costs accumulate over time and can be substantial.

Significant Administrative Burden

Running a trust requires ongoing record-keeping, tax filing, and trustee meetings.

Trusts are not a "set and forget" arrangement. Trustees have legal duties to keep accurate records, prepare accounts, file tax returns, and act in the best interests of the beneficiaries. If you are a trustee of your own trust, this administrative burden falls on you. Failure to comply with trustee obligations can result in personal liability.

Mortgage and Insurance Complications

High Risk

Lenders and insurers may treat trust-owned property differently — and less favourably.

Most residential mortgage lenders will not lend against a property held in trust, or will impose significantly more restrictive terms. If you have an existing mortgage, your lender's consent is required before transferring the property into trust — and many lenders will refuse. Buildings insurance policies may also need to be reviewed and reissued in the name of the trustees, which can affect premiums and cover.

Complex Tax Implications

High Risk

Trusts can trigger unexpected tax charges — including inheritance tax, capital gains tax, and income tax.

Placing your home in trust does not automatically reduce your inheritance tax liability. If you continue to live in the property, HMRC may treat it as a "gift with reservation of benefit" — meaning it remains in your taxable estate regardless of the trust. Discretionary trusts face a 10-year anniversary charge of up to 6% of the trust's value, and an exit charge when assets leave the trust. Capital gains tax private residence relief may also be lost or restricted.

Family Friction and Beneficiary Issues

Children named as beneficiaries do not own the property — and must seek trustee permission to use it.

Putting a house in trust for children is a common intention, but it often creates tension. The children have a beneficial interest in the property but no right to occupy or use it without trustee consent. If family relationships deteriorate, or if beneficiaries disagree with trustee decisions, disputes can arise that are costly and distressing to resolve.

Limited Protection from Creditors

Revocable trusts offer little or no protection against creditors.

A common misconception is that placing a property in trust protects it from creditors. In reality, assets in a revocable trust remain accessible to creditors because you retain control over them. Even irrevocable trusts can be challenged if the transfer was made to deliberately defeat creditors — a transaction at an undervalue that can be set aside by the courts.

Why a House Trust Might Backfire: The Tax Reality

Tax is one of the most misunderstood aspects of property trusts. Here is what you actually need to know.

Inheritance Tax: Gift with Reservation

If you continue to live in the property, HMRC treats it as a "gift with reservation of benefit"
The property remains in your taxable estate — the trust achieves nothing for IHT purposes
To avoid this, you must pay a full market rent to the trust — which most people cannot or will not do
Pre-owned asset tax (POAT) may also apply, creating an annual income tax charge

Discretionary Trust Charges

10-year anniversary charge: up to 6% of the trust's value every 10 years
Exit charge: a proportionate charge when assets leave the trust
Entry charge: if the property value exceeds the nil-rate band (currently £325,000), an immediate 20% IHT charge applies
These charges can significantly erode the value of the estate over time

Capital Gains Tax

Transferring your home into trust is a disposal for CGT purposes
Private Residence Relief (PRR) may be available at the point of transfer if the property is your main home
Once in trust, PRR may be lost or restricted — meaning future gains are taxable
Trustees pay CGT at 24% on residential property gains (2024/25 rate)

Stamp Duty Land Tax

Transferring a mortgaged property into trust triggers SDLT on the outstanding mortgage
The 3% SDLT surcharge for additional dwellings may apply in some circumstances
SDLT must be paid within 14 days of completion of the transfer
This is an upfront cost that many people fail to factor into their planning

Alternatives to Putting Your House in Trust

Depending on your goals, there may be simpler, less costly, and more effective ways to achieve the same outcome.

A Well-Drafted Will

For most people, a carefully drafted will achieves the same estate planning goals as a trust — at a fraction of the cost and complexity. A will can include specific gifts, trusts for minor children, and inheritance tax planning provisions.

Tenants in Common Arrangement

Owning property as tenants in common (rather than joint tenants) allows each owner to leave their share to whoever they choose in their will. This is a simple, low-cost way to protect your share of the family home.

Lifetime Gifting

Gifting property outright during your lifetime may be simpler than a trust, though it carries its own tax implications under the 7-year rule. Specialist advice is essential before making any significant gift.

Lasting Power of Attorney

An LPA ensures that someone you trust can manage your property and finances if you lose capacity — without the need for a trust structure.

When Might a Property Trust Still Be Appropriate?

Despite the disadvantages, there are specific circumstances where a property trust can be the right solution — with careful planning and specialist advice.

Protecting assets for vulnerable beneficiaries

A discretionary trust can protect a property for a beneficiary who lacks capacity to manage their own affairs, or who has addiction or debt problems.

Blended family situations

A life interest trust can allow a surviving spouse to live in the property while ensuring it ultimately passes to children from a previous relationship.

Sophisticated IHT planning

In some high-value estates, trusts form part of a broader inheritance tax planning strategy — but only where the numbers genuinely justify the complexity and cost.

Business property and agricultural land

Trusts can be effective for holding business or agricultural property where Business Property Relief or Agricultural Property Relief applies, reducing or eliminating the IHT charge.

The key point: a trust should only be used where it is genuinely the most appropriate solution for your specific circumstances — not because it has been recommended by a non-specialist or marketed as a way to avoid tax or care fees. Always take advice from a qualified solicitor who specialises in wills, trusts, and estate planning.

Speak to a wills and estates solicitor today. Sensitive, professional advice — costs explained clearly before any work begins.

No obligation — talk through your options first. Chester, Cheshire & North Wales.

SRA Regulated

Sensitive & Confidential

Free Initial Consultation

Chester, Cheshire & North Wales

Speak to a Wills Solicitor

Laura Kirton — Wills & Probate Solicitor

Darren Steele — STEP Member

Nikolina Vukovic — Legal Executive

David Stahler — Estates Executive

Frequently Asked Questions

Does putting my house in trust avoid inheritance tax?

Not necessarily. If you continue to live in the property after transferring it into trust, HMRC will treat it as a "gift with reservation of benefit" and include it in your taxable estate. To avoid this, you would need to pay a market rent to the trust — which most people are unwilling or unable to do. Specialist inheritance tax advice is essential before using a trust for this purpose.

Can I still live in my house if it is in a trust?

This depends on the type of trust and how it is structured. With a life interest trust, you can retain the right to live in the property for your lifetime. However, if you simply transfer the property into a discretionary trust, your right to occupy is at the trustees' discretion — not guaranteed. The trust deed must be carefully drafted to protect your position.

What is the difference between a revocable and irrevocable trust?

A revocable trust can be changed or cancelled by the person who created it (the settlor) during their lifetime. An irrevocable trust cannot be changed once established without the consent of all beneficiaries and, in some cases, a court order. Irrevocable trusts offer more protection from creditors but involve a permanent loss of control.

Will putting my house in trust protect it from care home fees?

This is a common misconception. Local authorities can look back at asset transfers made in the preceding years and treat a deliberate deprivation of assets as still belonging to you for care fee assessment purposes. Placing your home in trust specifically to avoid care fees is unlikely to succeed and may be challenged. You should take specialist advice before attempting this.

Do I need to register a property trust with HMRC?

Yes. Since 2022, most UK trusts — including property trusts — must be registered with HMRC's Trust Registration Service (TRS), even if they have no tax liability. Failure to register can result in penalties. Your solicitor can handle the registration as part of the trust setup.

What are the alternatives to putting my house in trust?

Depending on your goals, alternatives include a well-drafted will (which can include trust provisions), changing from joint tenants to tenants in common, lifetime gifting, or making a Lasting Power of Attorney. Each option has different tax, legal, and practical implications. A specialist solicitor can help you identify the most appropriate approach for your circumstances.

Can a trust be challenged after I die?

Yes. A trust can be challenged on grounds including lack of capacity, undue influence, or deliberate deprivation of assets. Beneficiaries who feel they have been unfairly excluded may also bring claims under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975. Careful drafting and professional advice reduce — but do not eliminate — the risk of challenge.

Is a trust right for me?

A trust may be appropriate in specific circumstances — for example, to protect assets for vulnerable beneficiaries, to manage complex family situations, or as part of a sophisticated inheritance tax planning strategy. However, for most homeowners, the disadvantages outweigh the benefits. The starting point should always be a conversation with a specialist solicitor who can assess your individual circumstances.

Not Sure Whether a Trust is Right for You?

Our specialist wills and trusts solicitors in Chester can assess your circumstances and recommend the most appropriate estate planning strategy — without the jargon.